Katie Holmes recommended her classic ugly shoes to me, so I decided to buy these styles.

While strolling (well, sweating) through the streets of New York City last weekend, I noticed an interesting type of footwear that kept popping up: Along with chunky sneakers, lightweight flip-flops, and mesh ballet flats, fisherman sandals greeted me on nearly every block.

Though I was initially hesitant about these polarizing sandals, now seeing them styled in so many different ways has me on the hunt for a pair of my own. And to give me even more encouragement, Katie Holmes, a master of effortlessly put-together style, has also worn the style on multiple occasions. Recently, she paired her favorite fisherman sandals with a pair of relaxed lounge pants, proving that they can spice up even the most casual of outfits.

As I’m slowly preparing my closet for fall, I’ve found that Fisherman’s sandals are the perfect transitional footwear. Plus, loose-fitting bottoms like Holmes’ are a great alternative to jeans for days when I just can’t be bothered to put on “real” pants. Luckily, Amazon is chock-full of similar sandals and pants, with prices starting at just $17.

Katie Holmes-style fisherman sandals and loose pants

A pair of light brown suede fisherman sandals similar to Holmes’ shoes are on sale for nearly half the retail price. They’re designed for maximum comfort with adjustable straps, a cushioned insole, and a supportive lug outsole. I purchased these sandals in a muted sandal color, but they’re also available in brown leather, light blue suede, and black leather.

With a breathable strap design, non-slip insole, and supportive footbed, these fisherman sandals are perfect for long walks. Plus, the distinctive square toe design gives the shoes a unique vibe, adding a more structured touch to the classic silhouette. Having received “tons of compliments” in reviews, these sandals are available in beige, navy, and brown. You can get them for just $30.

I’m short and always want to look taller, so these platform sandals are at the top of my wishlist. Thanks to the cushioned footbed, the sandals are comfortable to wear all day. Plus, the thick straps are made from durable leather and can be worn in any season.

If you think sneakers are the only comfortable shoes to walk in, think again: these $34 sandals feature a non-slip rubber outsole and cushioned arch support, making them perfect for walking in. Copy Holmes with this brown suede pair, or pick up the shoes in other colors like white, navy, and beige.

The change in seasons means it’s time to swap out breezy shorts for looser pants, and these cozy bottoms will be the perfect addition to your fall wardrobe. “So soft and comfy,” one shopper said, while another commented, “The best relaxed pants.”

Designed with breathable fabric, a high-rise waistband and flattering pleats, these lounge pants are perfect for lounging on the couch, running errands or just taking a stroll. They’re tall enough to avoid any pajama vibes and are made from wrinkle-resistant fabric.

Of course, no closet staple is complete without a silky-soft sweatshirt. Reviewers say these wide-leg pants are “light and airy, yet opaque,” meaning you can wear them at home or outside. Plus, they’ve got pockets, which in my opinion is a must-have for bottoms. Choose from 21 different colors to recreate Katie Holmes’ laid-back style.